Podcast
The Hidden Cause of the Industrial Revolution
EconTalk
- Glorious Revolution Rewired Who Controls Property Rules
- The Glorious Revolution shifted ultimate power from the monarch to a Parliament dominated by landowners.
- Ben Southwood argues that empowered landowners used Parliament to systematically simplify property rights, unlocking investment in land and infrastructure. (Time 0:03:28)
- Entails Locked Land Use and Blocked Investment
- Early modern English property wasn’t fee simple: heirs, dowries, widows, and life tenancies constrained owners.
- These entails and settlements prevented mortgaging, selling, splitting, or altering land even when improvements were profitable. (Time 0:14:47)
- Strip Farming Gave Insurance But Stopped Innovation
- The open-field system split farms into many strips, giving insurance across plots but blocking coordinated innovations like new crops or horse ploughs.
- Changing crops or using larger-field techniques required reorganizing fragmented strips. (Time 0:21:21)
- Continuous Parliament Made Private Landfixes Possible
- Under monarchs who could prorogue Parliament, landowners avoided bringing private landfix bills because sessions were frequently shut down.
- After the Glorious Revolution, continuous parliamentary sessions let landowners use legislation to resolve tangled rights. (Time 0:28:59)
- Temporary Entail Loosening Bought Heirs’ Consent
- Parliament loosened specific entails temporarily then restored them, letting owners mortgage, sell timber, drain marshes, or cut canals with heirs’ future interests largely preserved.
- This case-by-case, consensualist approach reduced holdout opposition. (Time 0:31:47)
- Parliament Authorized Toll Roads and Canals at Scale
- Parliament routinely granted statutory authority for toll roads, canals, and navigable rivers and allowed land acquisition for them.
- Private promoters could charge tolls, raise loans, and repay investors, leading to massive infrastructure rollout. (Time 0:39:01)
- Faster Roads Expanded Markets and Enabled Specialization
- Improved transport transformed market scope: British road speeds rose from ~1.5–2.3 mph to ~8 mph by 1820, enabling national grain, manure, pottery, and textile markets.
- Lower inland transport costs enabled specialization and scale. (Time 0:40:40)
- Buy Off Holdouts To Unlock Land Reform Quickly
- To pass growth-friendly land reforms, build coalitions and design buyouts for those who would lose; buying off affected parties lowers veto risk.
- Southwood suggests growth reforms should offer clear upside to assemble larger coalitions. (Time 0:56:04)
- Use Graduated Density To Incentivize Land Assembly
- Use graduated density rules to reward assembled parcels with higher development rights, creating incentives to merge plots.
- Southwood cites New York’s historical diagonal setback rule and Rockefeller Center as examples of assembly-driven development. (Time 1:03:40)
- Adopt Land Assembly Districts With Fair Protections
- Consider land assembly districts or lower supermajority thresholds to overcome holdouts, modeled on historic enclosure and Israel’s Tama 38.
- Southwood notes Tama 38 uses two-thirds consent and requires developer housing during construction. (Time 1:05:36)